HFC/HC BLEND FOR CAR CLIMATE CONTROL WITH MINERAL OIL AS LUBRICANT

Abstract

Polyalkaline glycol is used as the lubricant with R134a in automobile air conditioning systems and it is well known that PAG oil is highly hygroscopic in nature. Presence of moisture in the system may detoriate the system and its performance. Hence PAG oil is replaced with conventional mineral oil. In the present study, a new refrigerant blend R134a/R290/R600a with mineral oil as lubricant has been tested in an experimental test rig with R12 as base line and compared with the published results. Pull down test from an average cabin temperature of 50°C is performed while the compressor speed is varied successively from 1500-2250-3000-800 rpm with a constant heat load of 2500 W, and held at that speed for duration of 30 minutes. Both R12 and the HFC-HC blend is tested in an experimental test rig and it has been found that this new mixture is almost in par with R12, However, a slight loss in system performance is encountered. But, considering the service issues associated with R134a and PAG oil, this new mixture can have better performance than R134a and PAG combination.

Keywords

Dates

  • Submission Date2010-07-03
  • Revision Date2010-12-12
  • Acceptance Date2011-03-25

DOI Reference

10.2298/TSCI100703028R

References

  1. Muir E.B., ‘Commercial refrigeration and CFCs', International Journal of Refrigeration 13 (1995) 106-112.
  2. Jung D.S. , R. Radermacher, ‘Performance simulation of single evaporator domestic refrigeration charged with pure and mixed refrigerants', International J. Refrigeration 14 (1991) 223-232.
  3. Camporese R., Bigolaro G, and Bobbo S. ‘Experimental evaluation of refrigerant mixtures as substitutes for R12 and R502', International Journal of Refrigeration, Vol. 20, PP.22-31
  4. Kim M.S., Mulroy W.J., Didion D.A., ‘Performance evaluation of two azeotropic refrigerant mixtures of HFC134a with HC290 and HC600a', Trans. ASME 116 (1994) 148-154.
  5. Jung D. Chong B.K., Byong B.L., Hong W.L., ‘Testing of a hydrocarbon mixture in domestic refrigerator', ASHRAE Trans. Symposia AT-96-19-3 (1996) 1077-1084.
  6. Sunami M. ‘ Physical and Chemical properties of refrigeration lubricants', ASHRAE Transactions, SE-99-14-02, (1999), pp.983-994.
  7. Tashtous B, Tahat M, Shudeifat M.A, ‘Experimental study of new refrigerant mixtures to replace R12 in domestic refrigerators'. Applied Thermal Engineering, 22(2002), pp495-506.
  8. Sekhar SJ, Senthil Kumar K, Mohan Lal D, ‘Ozone friendly HFC134a/HC mixture compatible with mineral oil in refrigeration system improves energy efficiency of a walk in cooler', Energy Conversion and Management, 45 (2004), 1175-86.
  9. Sekhar SJ, MohanLal D, ‘HFC134a/HC600a/HC290 mixture a retrofit for R12 systems', International Journal of Refrigeration, 28(2005), p.735-43.
  10. Ravikumar T. S., MohanLal D, ‘ On road performance analysis of R134a/R290/R600a refrigerant mixture in an automobile air conditioning system with mineral oil as lubricant', Energy Conversion and Management, 50, (2009), pp1891-1901.
  11. Lemmon E.W., Mclinden M.O., Huber M.L.,NIST, ‘Thermodynamic properties of refrigerants and refrigerant mixtures database (V 7.1). National Institute of Standards and Technology. 2003.
  12. Kiatsiriroat T, Euakit T. ‘Performance analysis of an automobile air conditioning system with R22/R124/R152a refrigerant', Applied Thermal Engineering,17(1997), 11, pp.1085-97. 10
  13. Joudi K. A., Mohammed A.K., Aljanabi K. ‘Experimental and computer performance study of an automotive air conditioning system with alternative refrigerants', Energy Conversion and Management, 44(2003), p.2959-76.
  14. Struss R.A, Jerome P, Henkes and Lawrence W. Gabbey. ‘Performance comparison of R134a and R12 with various heat exchangers in automotive air conditioning systems'. Society of Automotive Engineers, paper 900598.
  15. Hirata T, Aral H, Arahira K. ‘Automotive air conditioning system using R-134a
  16. comparison of refrigeration cycle characteristics of R12 and R-134a', SAE paper 930229.
  17. Dekieva T.W., Colmery S.H, ‘Fleet Trials with vehicles retrofitted to R-134a refrigerant and ester lubricants - Two years on the road', Society of Automotive Engineers. Paper no.932905. (1993) pp.2359-65.
  18. Herbert M. and Mohanlal D. , An experimental analysis of the effect of refrigerant charge level and outdoor condition on a window air conditioner., Thermal Science,14(2010), 4, pp. 1121-1138.
Volume 15, Issue 12, Pages391 -398