EDUCATING ENGINEERS FOR/IN SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT? WHAT WE KNEW, WHAT WE LEARNED, AND WHAT WE SHOULD LEARN
Abstract
In the past decade, several engineering universities, mainly in Europe, but also in Australia, North America, and Japan, have been addressing the issue of sustainable development. Engineering education in sustainable development has been discussed at many occasions. What questions have been addressed, what answers have been provided, and what are the main remaining topics for research into engineering education in sustainable development?
What should engineers learn regarding sustainable development? How to trigger institutional change within engineering schools: top-down or bottom-up? How to trigger cultural change, how to win the hearts and souls of the faculty? Curriculum change: starting new programs or changing existing ones? The contribution of active learning and project based learning? The role of external stakeholders, external cooperation? How to measure sustainable development learning effects? Practice what you preach: how to green the campus, diminish resource consumption and sustainabilise procurement? How to teach normative content in an academic context?
The paper, based mainly on the European literature on EESD of the last decade, discusses the answers that were provided and present an agenda for further research in EESD (This paper has mainly a European perspective. An overview of sustainable development engineering education in the USA can be found in [80].
Dates
- Submission Date2010-01-15
- Revision Date2010-05-12
- Acceptance Date2010-06-21
References
- Hadfield, M., Howarth, G., Consolidating Sustainable Development in Engineering Design: Educating the Educators, Proceedings on CD, Engineering Education in Sustainable Development, UPC, Barcelona, Spain, 2004, Available at: www.brandrg.plus.com/data/movens-motumque.pdf
- ***, WCED, the World Commission on Environment and Development, Our Common Future, Oxford University Press, Oxford-New York, 1987
- Azapagi}, A., Perdan, S., Shallcross, D., How Much Do Engineering Students Know about Sustainable Development? The Findings of an International Survey and Possible Implications for the Engineering Curriculum, European Journal of Engineering Education, 30 (2004), 1, pp. 1-19
- Wünschiers, R., Lindblad, P., Hydrogen in Education - a Biological Approach, International Journal of Hydrogen Energy, 27 (2002), 11-12, pp. 1131-1140
- Sotoudeh, M., Influence of Social Values on R&D of Clean Technologies in a Sustainable Development, Proceedings on CD, Engineering Education in Sustainable Development, INSA Lyon, France, 2006
- Fokkema, J. T. F., Janssen, L., Mulder, K., Sustainability: Necessity for a Prosperous Society, International Journal for Sustainability in Higher Education, 6 (2005), 3, pp. 219-228
- Ashford, N., Major Challenges to Engineering Education for Sustainable Development, What Has to Change to Make it Creative, Effective and Acceptable to the Established Disciplins?, International Journal of Sustainability in Higher Education, 5 (2004), 3, pp. 239-250
- Brand, R.G., Harnessing the Movens Motumque Phenomenon for Sustainability Engineers, Proceedings on CD, Engineering Education in Sustainable Development UPC, Barcelona, Spain, 2004, Available at:
- www.brandrg.plus.com/data/movens-motumque.pdf
- Dabrowsky, B., Multi Facet Approach to Applied Sustainability Education, Proceedings on CD, Engineering Education in Sustainable Development, INSA, Lyon, France, 2006
- Kastenhofer, K., Sotoudeh, M., Alphabet of Inter-Disciplinary Engineering Work in SD. Knowledge and skills, Proceedings on CD, Engineering Education in Sustainable Development, TU, Graz, Austria, 2008
- Lansu, A., How to Become Competent for Sustainable Development?, Proceedings on CD, Engineering Education in Sustainable Development, INSA, Lyon, France, 2006
- Smith, Ph., Sustainability is Not a Technological Problem!, Proceedings on CD, Engineering Education in Sustainable Development, TU Delft, The Netherlands, 2002
- Carabias-Hütter, V., Winistörfer, H., Evaluating the Social Dimension of Sustainable Development, Proceedings on CD, Engineering Education in Sustainable Development, UPC, Barcelona, Spain, 2004, Available at: www.brandrg.plus.com/data/movens-motumque.pdf
- de Jong, L., et al., Multidisciplinary Projects as Learning Tool for Sustainable Approaches, Experience and Some Critical Assessment, Proceedings on CD, Engineering Education in Sustainable Development, TU Delft, The Netherlands, 2002
- Fabregat, J., Human Values Related to Sustainable Development in Engineering Education, Proceedings on CD, Engineering Education in Sustainable Development, UPC, Barcelona, Spain, 2004, Available at:
- www.brandrg.plus.com/data/movens-motumque.pdf
- Sureda, B., de Felipe, J. J., Xercavins, J., Analysing Sustainability in Engineering Courses, Using a Reasoning Tool to Study Indicators and Indices, Proceedings on CD, Engineering Education in Sustainable Development, UPC, Barcelona, Spain, 2004, Available at:
- www.brandrg.plus.com/data/movens-motumque.pdf
- Segalas, J., Ferrer-Balas, D., Carillo, D., Sustainability Evaluation of Engineering Student Projects: A Guideline for the Sustainability Award by CETIB-UPC, Proceedings on CD, Engineering Education in Sustainable Development, UPC, Barcelona, 2004,Available at:
- www.brandrg.plus.com/data/movens-motumque.pdf
- Blinc, R., et al.., How to Achieve a Sustainable Future for Europe? Thermal Science, 12 (2008) 4, pp. 19-25
- Desha, C. J., Hargroves, K., Smith, M. H., Addressing the Time Lag Dilemma in Curriculum Renewal Towards Engineering Education for Sustainable Development, International Journal of Sustainability in Higher Education, 10 (2009), 2, pp. 184-199
- Holmberg, J., Drivers and Barriers for Implementing Sustainable Development Into Higher Education, Report from the Göteborg Workshop 2005, Proceedings on CD, Engineering Education in Sustainable Development, INSA, Lyon, France, 2006
- Ihsen, S., Schoeler, G., Brandt, D., Implementing Project Orientation Towards sustainability in the University - the Issue of Systemic Change, Proceedings on CD, Engineering Education in Sustainable Development, TU Delft, The Netherlands, 2002
- Massardier-Nageotte, V., et al., How to Integrate Sustainable Development in an Engineering University? The example of INSA-Lyon, Proceedings on CD, Engineering Education in Sustainable Development, INSA, Lyon, France, 2006
- Crofton, F., Heslop, S., Stone Walls, Labyrinths, Draw-Bridges and Side Doors in the Ivory Tower, Challenges and Opportunities for Sustainable Development in Higher Education, Proceedings on CD, Engineering Education in Sustainable Development, TU Delft, The Netherlands, 2002
- Esteban, F., Ferrer-Balas, D., Barceló, M., Participatory Processes and Institutional Debate Activities as Key Complementary Aspects for Embedding Sustainability in Higher Education, Proceedings on CD, Engineering Education in Sustainable Development, TU, Graz, Austria, 2008
- Venselaar, J., Roorda, N., Severijn, T., Integrating Sustainable Development in Engineering Education, The Novel CIRRUS Approach, Proceedings on CD, Engineering Education in Sustainable Development, TU Delft, The Netherlands, 2002
- Roorda, N., van Mansvelt, R., Policy Development for Sustainability in Higher Education - Results of AISHE Audits, Proceedings on CD, Engineering Education in Sustainable Development, TU, Delft, The Netherlands, 2002
- Ferrer-Balas, D., de Mingo, M., Sans, R., Network Education for Sustainability Based on Environmental Values of a Technological Campus. The ITINERA Project, Proceedings on CD, Engineering Education in Sustainable Development, UPC, Barcelona, 2004, Available at:
- www.brandrg.plus.com/data/movens-motumque.pdf
- Paten, C. J. K., et al., Critical Literacies for Engineers Portfolio, International Journal of Sustainability in Higher Education 6 (2005), 3, pp. 265-277
- Wiesner, P. K., Engineering Education in Sustainable Development: The Role of Professional Associations, Proceedings on CD, Engineering Education in Sustainable Development, UPC, Barcelona, Spain, 2004, Available at: www.brandrg.plus.com/data/movens-motumque.pdf
- de Werk, G., Mulder, K., Increasing value of Sustainability Education by Improving Sustainability of Research, Proceedings, of Engineering Education in Sustainable Development, TU, Graz, Austria, 2008
- Lourdel, N., et al., Introduction of Sustainable Development in Engineer's Curricula: Problematic and Evaluation Methods, International Journal of Sustainability in Higher Education, 6 (2006), 3, pp. 254-264
- Nichol, E., Sillitoe, J., How do Engineering Educators Understand Sustainability? Proceedings on CD, Engineering Education in Sustainable Development, INSA Lyon, France, 2006
- de Werk, G., Mulder, K.F., Interdisciplinary Education as a Way of Shaping Real Sustainable Engineers?, Proceedings on CD, Engineering Education in Sustainable Development, UPC, Barcelona, Spain, 2004, Available at: www.brandrg.plus.com/data/movens-motumque.pdf
- Peet, D. J., Mulder, K. F., Integrating SD into Engineering Courses that Are not Specifically SD Targeted, Proceedings on CD, Engineering Education in Sustainable Development, TU, Delft, The Netherlands, 2002
- Peet, D. J., Mulder, K. F., Bijma, A., Integrating SD into Engineering Courses at the Delft University of Technology: the Individual Interaction Method, International Journal of Sustainability in Higher Education, 5 (2004), 3, pp. 278-288
- Holmberg, J., et al., Embedding Sustainability in Higher Education through Interaction with Lecturers: Case Studies from Three European Technical Universities, European Journal of Engineering Education, 33 (2008), 3, pp. 271-282
- Mendieta, C., Environmental Engineers or Environmentalization of the Engineering?, Proceedings on CD, Engineering Education in Sustainable Development, UPC, Barcelona, Spain, 2004, Available at: www.brandrg.plus.com/data/movens-motumque.pdf
- Korevaar, G., et al., Master Programme Industrial Ecology - A New M. Sc. Curriculum in The Netherlands, Proceedings on CD, Engineering Education in Sustainable Development, UPC, Barcelona, Spain, 2004, Available at: www.brandrg.plus.com/data/movens-motumque.pdf
- Boyle, C., Master of Engineering Study in Sustainability Engineering, Proceedings on CD, Engineering Education in Sustainable Development, TU, Delft, The Netherlands, 2002
- Wennersten, R., Brandt, N., Sustainable Technology - A New Masters Program at the Royal Institute of Technology, Proceedings on CD, Engineering Education in Sustainable Development, UPC, Barcelona, Spain, 2004, Available at: www.brandrg.plus.com/data/movens-motumque.pdf
- Frouws, J. W., Overschie, M. G. F., Are Active Ways of Learning the Answers for Awareness Raising in Courses about Marine Technology in Sustainable Development, Proceedings on CD, Engineering Education in Sustainable Development, UPC, Barcelona, Spain, 2004, Available at:
- www.brandrg.plus.com/data/movens-motumque.pdf
- Lobera, P., Toharia, M., Álvarez, X., Technology through: A Proposal for a Dialogical and Interconnectivity-Based Pedagogy in Engineering Education, Proceedings, Engineering Education in Sustainable Development, INSA, Lyon, France, 2006
- Overschie, M., et al., Microteaching Sustainable Technological Innovation, Effective Knowledge Exchange in 15 Minutes, Proceedings on CD, Engineering Education in Sustainable Development, INSA, Lyon, France, 2006
- Anderson, P., Kusz, J. P., Engineering Education for the "Real" World, Educating Engineers to Meet Real Needs with Minimal Environmental Effects, Proceedings on CD, 1st Engineering Education in Sustainable Development, TU, Delft, The Netherlands, 2002
- Gallagher, C., Burek, S., Pahl, O., The Vertical Project and the Castlemilk Urban Windfarm - A Method of Promoting Interdisciplinary Student Work for Sustainable Development, Proceedings on CD, Engineering Education in Sustainable Development, UPC, Barcelona, Spain, 2004, Available at:
- www.brandrg.plus.com/data/movens-motumque.pdf
- Segalas, J., Engineering Education for a Sustainable Future, Ph. D. thesis, UPC Barcelona, Spain, 2009
- Germain, D., Chaudonneret, J., Training Course in Technical, Social and Managerial Knowledge and Skills through a Real Life Project, Proceedings on CD, Engineering Education in Sustainable Development, INSA, Lyon, France, 2006
- Rammelt, C. F., Boes, J., Technological Education and Projects in Developing Countries: Possibilities and Constraints, Proceedings on CD, Engineering Education in Sustainable Development, UPC, Barcelona, Spain, 2004, Available at: www.brandrg.plus.com/data/movens-motumque.pdf
- Schõn, S., Co-Operation Management as Part of Engineering Education, Proceedings on CD, Engineering Education in Sustainable Development, TU Delft, The Netherlands, 2002
- Installé, M., Teaching Sustainable Development Concept and Strategies Using Role Play Techniques: Experimentation and Evaluation, Proceedings on CD, Engineering Education in Sustainable Development, UPC, Barcelona, Spain, 2004, Available at: www.brandrg.plus.com/data/movens-motumque.pdf
- Planchard, F., Interactive Case-Studies, a Innovating and Relevant Approach for Teaching Sustainable Development, Proceedings on CD, Engineering Education in Sustainable Development, INSA Lyon, France, 2006
- van Bueren, E. M., Mayer, I. S. Bots, P. W. G., Developing an Educational Game for Sustainable Urban Development, Proceedings on CD, Engineering Education in Sustainable Development, UPC, Barcelona, Spain, 2004, Available at: www.brandrg.plus.com/data/movens-motumque.pdf
- de Werk, G., et al., Shaping Sustainable Professionals. The Need to Adapt Learning Processes by Involving Students, The Steps that Have to be Taken, Proceedings on CD, Engineering Education in Sustainable Development, INSA Lyon, France, 2006
- Bélières, F., Improving Understanding of Social and Environmental Responsibility of Companies for Students: Partnership between Higher Education Schools and IMS, Proceedings on CD, Engineering Education in Sustainable Development, INSA Lyon, France, 2006
- Hillebrecht, K., Behnsen, A., Kranert, M., Economic Importance of Material Flux Management and Waste Minimization for Small and Medium Sized Enterprises, Proceedings on CD, Engineering in Sustainable Development Conference, UPC, Barcelona, Spain, 2004, Available at:
- www.brandrg.plus.com/data/movens-motumque.pdf
- Brezet, H., Silvester, S., Diehl, J. C., An Evaluation of the Sustainability Impact of 10 years of Design for Sustainability M. Sc. Projects, Proceedings on CD, Engineering Education in Sustainable Development, TU, Delft, The Netherlands, 2002
- Barke, R. P., Abraham, G. L., "Civic Engineering" and the Integration of Engineering Design and Policy Design in Instruction about Sustainable Development, Proceedings on CD, Engineering Education in Sustainable Development, INSA, Lyon, France, 2006
- Dyer, M., Holm, S., Collaboration between Tampere Polytechnic and Moreenia, the Centre for Urban Environment, Proceedings on CD, Engineering Education in Sustainable Development, UPC, Barcelona, Spain, 2004, Available at: www.brandrg.plus.com/data/movens-motumque.pdf
- Dyer, M., Holm, S., A Partnership in Environmental Technology, Proceedings on CD, Engineering Education in Sustainable Development, INSA Lyon, France, 2006
- Narodoslawsky, M., Technical Universities as Platforms for the Societal Discourse about Sustainable Development - The Case of the "Forumsakademie" at the Graz University of Technology, Proceedings on CD, Engineering Education in Sustainable Development, INSA, Lyon, France, 2006
- Mader, C., RCEs - Local and Global Movement Towards SD, Indicators for Change Process, Proceedings on CD, Engineering Education in Sustainable Development, TU, Graz, Austria, 2008
- Scholz, R. W., Tietje, O., Embedded Case-Study Methods, Integrating Quantitative and Qualitative Knowledge, Sage Publications Ltd, Thousend Oaks, Cal., USA, 2001
- Lundholm, C. H., Learning about Environmental Issues. Post- and Undergraduate Students' Interpretations of Environmental Content, International Journal of Sustainability in Higher Education, 6 (2005), 3, pp. 242-253
- Iuli, R. J., Helldén, G., Using Concept Maps as a Research Tool in Science Education Research, Concept Maps: Theory, Methodology, Technology, Proceedings on CD, 1st International Conference on Concept Mapping, Pamplona, Spain, 2004
- Segalàs, J., Ferrer-Balas, D., Mulder, K., Using Conceptual Maps to Measure Learning on Sustainable Development: Case Studies from European Technological Universities, Proceedings on CD, Engineering Education in Sustainable Development, INSA, Lyon, France, 2006
- Cantalapiedra, I. R., Bosch, M., López, F., Involvement of Final Architecture Diploma Projects in the Analysis of the Energy Performance of UPC Buildings as a way of Teaching Practical Sustainability, Proceedings on CD, Engineering Education in Sustainable Development, UPC, Barcelona, Spain, 2004, Available at: www.brandrg.plus.com/data/movens-motumque.pdf
- Ferrer-Balas, D., de Mingo, M., Pujadas, M., Marí, A., UPC Sustainable 2015, An Action Plan for the Future Built on a Participatory Evaluation, Proceedings on CD, Engineering Education in Sustainable Development, INSA, Lyon, France, 2006
- Piera, J., et al., The Project "Laboratori Real" at the UPC: The Opportunity for Greening Engineering Subjects, Proceedings on CD, Engineering Education in Sustainable Development, UPC, Barcelona, Spain, 2004, Available at: www.brandrg.plus.com/data/movens-motumque.pdf
- Sammalisto, K., Environmental Management Systems - a Way Towards Sustainable Development in Universities, Ph. D. thesis, IIIEE, Lund University, Lund, Sweden, 2007
- Brandt, N., Strandberg, Lg., Politics and Science: The Role of Sustainable Development in Engineering Education, Proceedings on CD, Engineering Education in Sustainable Development, UPC, Barcelona, Spain, 2004, Available at: www.brandrg.plus.com/data/movens-motumque.pdf
- Jimenez-Beltrán, D., Sustainable Development, Conditions for Change, Engineers' Responsibilities and Expectations, Proceedings on CD, Engineering Education in Sustainable Development, UPC, Barcelona, Spain, 2004, Available at: www.brandrg.plus.com/data/movens-motumque.pdf
- Rei , J., Portela, O., Ethics and Sustainable Development Issues in Engineering Education, Proceedings on CD, Engineering Education in Sustainable Development, INSA, Lyon, France, 2006
- Mulder, K. F., Don't Preach, Practice! Value Laden Statements in Academic Sustainability Education, International Journal of Sustainability in Higher Education, 11 (2010) 1, pp. 74-85
- Lucena, J., Schneider, J,. Leydens, J., Where is "Community"? Engineering Education and Sustainable Community Development, European Journal of Engineering Education, 33 (2008), 3, pp. 307-319
- Carlos-Aguado, J., Teaching to Doubt, Proceedings on CD, Engineering Education in Sustainable Development, UPC, Barcelona, Spain, 2004, Available at:
- www.brandrg.plus.com/data/movens-motumque.pdf
- Lemkowitz, S., et al., Intellectually Responsible Teaching of Subjects with Strong Normative Content, Like ‘Sustainability, at Universities, Proceedings on CD, Engineering Education in Sustainable Development, TU Delft, The Netherlands, 2002
- Pérez-Foguet, A., Oliete-Josa, S., Saz-Carranza, A., Practices, Knowledge and Values, Teaching Technology for Human Development to Engineering Students, International Journal of Sustainability in Higher Education, 6 (2005), 3, pp. 278-303
- Albrecht, P., Burandt, S., Schaltegger, S., Do Sustainability Projects Stimulate Organizational Learning?, International Journal of Sustainability in Higher Education, 8 (2007), 4, pp. 403-415
- de Werk, G., Cruz, Y., Klein, M., The Vision of the BEASTS, Why we Need an International Student Association and what Should it do?, Proceedings on CD, Engineering Education in Sustainable Development, UPC, Barcelona, Spain, 2004, Available at:
- www.brandrg.plus.com/data/movens-motumque.pdf
- Allen, D., et al, Benchmarking Sustainable Engineering Education: Final Report, EPA grant X3-83235101-0, 2008, available at
- www.csengin.org/BSEE_Final_Report_31Dec.08_No_Appen_D.pdf (12 May 2010)
Volume
14,
Issue
3,
Pages625 -639